I’ve made a lot of birthday cakes in my 18 years as a mother and this vanilla cake is by far the most requested. It’s moist and delicious and pound-cake like. Plus it makes more than a typical 9x13 cake so you can feed the masses. I’ll show you how easy it is and you’ll never want to go the easy box route again.

This vanilla cake has been made several times with the strawberry components, but the cake part alone is versatile enough to take on other flavors! We’ve made variations using blueberries, toasted coconut, freeze-dried raspberry buttercream, lemon cream, and chocolate.
It’s a showstopper for sure. Just make sure you don’t overbake it because it’ll dry out pretty quickly.
If you’re looking for a gluten free and/or dairy free cake, try this recipe: Gluten Free Yellow Cake with Chocolate Frosting.

Why You'll Love this Strawberry Vanilla Cake Recipe
This cake, guys. It's so, so good. The fresh strawberries in the center and the strawberry cream cheese frosting is to die for. It's like a layer cake version of strawberry shortcake.
This vanilla cake alone -- without the filling and frosting recipes -- is such a great recipe! It feeds a lot of people and it has a sturdier texture (almost like pound cake but not quite) so you can "build" things with it, if that's your thing.
It comes together like most homemade cakes -- mixing the dry ingredients and gradually adding the wet ingredients.
You might be surprised to see that this is a vanilla cake recipe without buttermilk. However, it has sour cream which gives it hint of acidity and creates that soft, but semi-dense texture instead of a traditional fluffy vanilla cake.
Let's get started!

First, you should know that this makes a lot of cake -- about 50% more than a regular cake mix. I've made this cake dozens of times with a lot of different pan and layering situations. It's flexible, which is nice.
Make sure to see the tips further down on assembling this cake. It can get a little tricky -- especially with 3 or 4 layers.
TIP: The weight of this batter is roughly 1800g, in case you'd like to get precise with a kitchen scale when you put the cake batter into the pans. That will give you nice, even layers.

Ingredients for Vanilla and Strawberry Cake
For the Frosting:
- Cream cheese
- Unsalted butter
- Powdered sugar
- Strawberry jam (Seedless)
- Heavy whipping cream
For the Cake:
- Cake flour
- Salt
- Baking powder
- Baking soda
- Sugar
- Unsalted butter
- Eggs
- Vanilla extract
- Ssour cream
For Garnish:
- Strawberry jam (Seedless)
- Fresh strawberries
How to Make Vanilla Cake With Strawberry Filling
- For the frosting, beat cream cheese and butter in a large bowl until smooth. You'll probably want to use an electric mixer for this so you don't end up with lumps. Stop every now and then to scrape down the sides of the bowl. Beat in sugar, then jam.
- Beat heavy cream in a separate, chilled, bowl until stiff peaks form. Fold whipped cream into frosting. Cover; chill for a couple of hours until it's firm enough to spread and won't slide off your cake.
- For the cake, preheat the oven to 325 degrees F. Butter and flour three 9-inch round cake pans.
- In a medium bowl whisk together flour, salt, baking powder, and baking soda. In a large bowl or stand mixer, cream butter and sugar together until light and fluffy. Add eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition. Beat in vanilla. Add sour cream, and beat for 30 seconds. Add flour mixture in three additions, beating to blend after each addition.
- Divide batter into prepared pans. Bake cake until a toothpick inserted into the center comes out clean and the top is light golden brown, 35-40 minutes. Remove from oven and cool for 10 minutes.
- Run a sharp knife around the edges of the pans, then turn cakes out onto a rack to cool completely.
- Using a serrated knife to gently slice off any domed tops of the cake so they're flatter. Place one half, bottom-side up, on a cake plate. Spread 2 T of strawberry jam over the cake, then spread ¾ c of the frosting over the jam. Arrange ¾ c of the sliced strawberries on top of the frosting in a single layer. Repeat two more times with cake layer, jam, frosting, and strawberries. Top with remaining cake layer, bottom side up.
- Spread two cups of frosting over the top and sides of the cake in a thin layer, then frost with remaining frosting. Stir remaining jam to loosen, then spoon teaspoonfuls onto the top and sides of the cake. Use the back of a spoon to swirl jam decoratively into the frosting.
- If you won't be cutting the cake for more than an hour or so, store it chilled until you're ready.
Pan Sizes and Layering Options:
- 3 9-inch pans for a 3-layer cake. No slicing cake layers necessary.
- 8-inch pans that are 2-inches deep for a thick 2-layer cake or split into 4 layers. If you do 4 layers, consider using a couple of wooden dowels stabbed into two places in the cake to stabilize it so it doesn't slide.
- 4 7-inch cake pans for 4 layers (see Hogwarts castle below!)
- 9x13 pan and pile all of the strawberries and frosting on top.
- 9x13 cake removed from the pan onto a big platter and split into 2 layers.

Tips for Making the Perfect Vanilla Cake with Strawberry Frosting
If you choose to slice the cake to make thinner layers, refrigerating the cake for a few hours. It makes it A LOT easier to cut cake layers as opposed to slicing room temperature cake. I also use a long bread knife which makes it easer, too.
Line the bottoms of your baking pans with parchment paper so the cake releases easily. It's extra insurance.
To keep your cake platter looking nice lay strips of parchment paper around the edges. I put a blob of frosting in the middle of the strips to keep the cake from sliding around.

Make the sliced strawberries thin. And if you want a more robust fresh strawberry filling, use more! I don't recommend this if you're doing a 4-layer cake, though, or it will be more difficult to cut and will be unstable. You don't want this falling over.
I like to arrange my strawberries prettily before I put on the second cake layer, but, honestly it doesn't matter since it will get covered up anyway. Add the next layer, followed by more cream frosting and sliced strawberries.

How to Make the Strawberry Buttercream for Vanilla Strawberry Cake
This might be the only cake I've made where you make the frosting first.
The frosting on this cake is unique -- a typical cream cheese frosting (butter, cream cheese, powdered sugar) with strawberry jam and freshly whipped cream added to make nice, soft peaks.
So, it's fluffy and light and super delicious -- make sure you use a large bowl. You'll want to get every last bit off the sides of the bowl.

This frosting can be a little finicky the first time (as you can see from the comments). After making it several times, here are a few tips for you.
Tips for Making the Strawberry Buttercream for Vanilla and Strawberry Cake
- Make sure to beat the heavy cream well -- to stiff peaks with a whisk attachment or a hand mixer. You don't want the cream to be runny at all.
- Chill the frosting well before you spread it on the cake. At least 2 hours.
- Swirling jam into the frosting (once you get it on the cake) will add more moisture. If the consistency of your frosting is a little loose, refrigerate it for a couple of hours before you swirl in the jam, use a light hand with the jam, or limit the jam to just the top.
- Return the cake to the refrigerator so it doesn't get too warm. The frosting will start to slide if it sits out for several hours.

- For the top of the cake, I put fresh strawberries and mint leaves to keep a simple cake top.
- I've also topped it with Chocolate Covered Strawberries. It's super delicious and beautiful that way, too.

It's been our go-to of all white cake recipes for over 10 years. I'll never use a vanilla cake mix again. Here are a few ways we've adapted it over the years:
Ways to Adapt this Strawberry and Vanilla Cake
Toasted Coconut
Omit the strawberries and frost it with regular butter cream with some coconut extract added and cover the outside of the cake with toasted coconut. My 80-year-old grandpa really loved it as his last birthday cake.
Change up the Berries
We did a blueberry My Little Pony version for my 5-year-old.
Vanilla Bean
For a boost of vanilla flavor, try using vanilla bean paste (or a fresh vanilla bean) along with the vanilla extract in the cake recipe.
Ice Cream Cake
Cut the recipe in half, bake it in a springform cheesecake pan, then when it's cooled off, top it with a quart of softened ice cream. Then freeze the whole thing and frost it. Our kids ask for ice cream cake like this so often!
Hogwart's Cake
The cake layers can easily be colored, too. We made a Harry Potter Hogwart's cake for my oldest's 11th birthday and I included some details about that below the recipe card.

Just for nostalgia, here's the photo from the original post -- the one that went bonkers on Pinterest for YEARS.
It was taken after my daughter's party with a regular point-and-shoot camera when I realized I hadn't gotten a decent photo of the inside.
If you have any other questions about this cake, feel free to comment below or email me at natalie@perrysplate.com!
How to Serve Strawberry and Vanilla Cake
This delicious cake can be served as is! Garnish with some extra strawberries if you like.
How to store Strawberry Vanilla Cake
Store this cake in the fridge until you are ready to serve it to prevent the icing from getting too soft. Leftovers can also be kept for up to 3 days.
If you make this recipe, be sure to post it to social media and tag me at @perrysplate or #perrysplate so I can send you some love!
FAQs
Yes. The frosting will start to slide if this cake isn’t kept cool.
The icing between the cake and the strawberries prevents the cake from getting soggy.
Allowing your cake layers to cool completely on a wire rack will ensure they don’t get soggy. Make sure you turn them out of the baking tins about 10 minutes after you remove them from the oven.
Vanilla Cake with Strawberry Cream Frosting
This strawberry layer cake has tender stacks of fluffy vanilla cake sandwiched with fresh strawberries and the best strawberry cream cheese frosting ever.
Ingredients
For the Frosting:
- 2 8-oz packages of cream cheese, room temperature
- 1 cup (2 sticks) unsalted butter, room temperature
- 4 cups powdered sugar
- ½ cup seedless strawberry jam
- ¾ cup chilled heavy whipping cream
For the Cake:
- 3 cups cake flour
- ¾ teaspoon salt
- ½ teaspoon baking powder
- ½ teaspoon baking soda
- 2 ½ cups sugar
- 1 cup (2 sticks) unsalted butter, room temperature
- 7 large eggs
- 2 Tablespoons vanilla extract
- 1 cup sour cream
For Garnish:
- 6 Tablespoons plus ⅓ c seedless strawberry jam
- 2 ¼ pounds strawberries, hulled, sliced (about 6 cups), divided
Instructions
- For the frosting, beat cream cheese and butter in a large bowl until smooth. You'll probably want to use an electric mixer for this so you don't end up with lumps. Stop every now and then to scrape down the sides of the bowl. Beat in sugar, then jam.
- Beat heavy cream in a separate, chilled, bowl until stiff peaks form. Fold whipped cream into frosting. Cover; chill for a couple of hours until it's firm enough to spread and won't slide off your cake.
- For the cake, preheat the oven to 325 degrees F. Butter and flour three 9-inch round cake pans.
- In a medium bowl whisk together flour, salt, baking powder, and baking soda. In a large bowl or stand mixer, cream butter and sugar together until light and fluffy. Add eggs, one at a time, beating after each addition. Beat in vanilla. Add sour cream, and beat for 30 seconds. Add flour mixture in three additions, beating to blend after each addition.
- Divide batter into prepared pans. Bake cake until a toothpick inserted into the center comes out clean and the top is light golden brown, 35-40 minutes. Remove from oven and cool for 10 minutes.
- Run a sharp knife around the edges of the pans, then turn cakes out onto a rack to cool completely.
- Using a serrated knife to gently slice off any domed tops of the cake so they're flatter. Place one half, bottom-side up, on a cake plate. Spread 2 T of strawberry jam over the cake, then spread ¾ c of the frosting over the jam. Arrange ¾ c of the sliced strawberries on top of the frosting in a single layer. Repeat two more times with cake layer, jam, frosting, and strawberries. Top with remaining cake layer, bottom side up.
- Spread two cups of frosting over the top and sides of the cake in a thin layer, then frost with remaining frosting. Stir remaining jam to loosen, then spoon teaspoonfuls onto the top and sides of the cake. Use the back of a spoon to swirl jam decoratively into the frosting.
- If you won't be cutting the cake for more than an hour or so, store it chilled until you're ready.
Notes
There are a lot of tips for this recipe in the blog post, but here are the most important:
- Make sure you beat your cream well until it's stiff. Otherwise your frosting won't be stiff enough after it has been chilled. And chill it for a long time. You'll want it as cold as possible while you're working with it.
- If your frosting is looser than you expect, don't swirl jam into it. It'll just add more moisture. Or just swirl a little on the top of the cake instead.
- If you don't have cake flour, substitute with all-purpose flour, removing 2 Tablespoons of the flour per cup and adding 2 Tablespoons of cornstarch or arrowroot powder in its place.
Nutrition Information
Yield 20 Serving Size 1 sliceAmount Per Serving Calories 549Total Fat 16gSaturated Fat 9gTrans Fat 0gUnsaturated Fat 5gCholesterol 108mgSodium 249mgCarbohydrates 95gFiber 2gSugar 70gProtein 7g
The information shown is an estimate provided by an online nutrition calculator. It should not be considered a substitute for a professional nutritionist’s advice.
This post may contain affiliate links. Any purchases made by using these links won't cost you any extra and helps keep my content free. These links may be Amazon links as I am part of the Amazon Associate Program.
Details for the Hogwarts Cake

I'm not really into cake decorating or fondant or anything super fancy. This was about as fancy as I get.
I used two kinds of ice cream cones for the turrets (the bottoms trimmed on a couple to make them different heights), and various shades of gray vanilla buttercream and Wilton's silver/black sprinkle pack.
Oh, and silver food spray, because when we veer off the healthy path, sometimes we go far. #yolo
See those chocolate frogs?? So cute, right? I just got an inexpensive frog mold on Amazon and used good quality melting chocolate.

The inside layers were colors to represent all of the Hogwarts houses and layered with chocolate buttercream. This was probably the best job I did at getting all of the layers evenly sized.
I used a 7-inch round pan and put 450g of batter in each layer.





ElegantSnobbery says
Holy Toledo, that cake is awesome. i LOVE those butterflies!! How lucky Sophie is!!!
Sarah (Team Chilton) says
That cake was so stinkin awesome. That is my goal from here on out...actually make a cake for my kids' birthdays (no ice cream social this year, and least not for the November birthday...hehe...what was I thinking). Maybe we can think of something else that is boyish that I can use your butterfly instructions for. I love this cake! Maybe JD needs to learn how to make a cake for MY birthday.
Cindy Siders says
You did a really good job with this cake!
I have made this cake twice from the Bon Appetit recipe and I wanted to comment on it officially but could no longer find the recipe on Bon Appetit's website. This is a fantastic cake tastewise, but I have had the hardest time assembling this thing both times that I have made it. The reason is that the frosting, even after hours in the refrigerator, softens within minutes of being in room temp. With a 9x13 cake cut into layers, this was probably not a big deal for you, but if you have the 9" round cakes, the layers just slide all over the place as the frosting melts and oozes out the side. The second time I made it, I chilled everything, including the cake layers. When I put it together, it was better than the first time, but I still had to stick some cocktail stirrers in it to hold the layers straight while we carried it to a party. Anyway, it tastes FANTASTIC even if it looks a mess.
Next time I am just doing a 9x13 with a thick layer of jam, berries, and frosting on the top. No layers for me!
CHews says
Add some unflavored gelatin to the whipped cream.... Cook's Illustrated suggests that addition and I've had no problems with similar icings of theirs.
charv says
I was just about the same thing about the geletin.
Kathy Wallis says
I just made this cake, using 9" pans, and it worked out beautifully, although I agree that the frosting is pretty soft. I did an outside layer of frosting and then cooled cake and frosting some more before adding the final layer of frosting. I soaked the strawberries in Grand Marnier, poured off the juices, and then used them for the interior as well as on top. Took photos, but can't figure out how to post those....haven't tasted it yet, but did taste the components! Yum!
Natalie Perry says
Thank you so much for sharing! And for the photos! I'm glad you were able to work with that frosting and adapted the recipe to your liking. xoxo
Natalie @ Perrys' Plate says
Hi Cindy!
Thanks for the heads up about layering 9-inch cakes. I've only made this cake once and it was as described above. I don't remember the layers and frosting being particularly slippery, but maybe that's due to the 9x13 layers. Huh.
It's a good thing it tastes great, right! :)
Rosa Contello says
You did a beautiful job on the cake. Can not wait to make it for my family. Thank you.
Natalie says
Thank you! I hope you all enjoy it. We sure did :)
stephanie says
Hey! Is the "T" suppose to be teaspoons or tablespoons? Btw, beautiful job on the cake!
Natalie says
Big T is tablespoon! Sorry for the confusion. I should really quit being lazy when I type out recipes :)
luis says
The strawberry jam makes the cake extra sweet and generic. (of course this is my personal taste). Try it next time with layers of fresh strawberries mixed with a little sugar, then add the whipped cream on top. The cake will absorb the strawberry juices, making it very moist and fresh. I use Chantilly cream, made with crème fraiche ( I buy it in Whole Foods) . Try it, you will taste the difference.
Natalie says
I agree with you somewhat. I didn't mind the jam in the layers (because there are also fresh strawberries), but I didn't like it all over the cake, which is why I didn't smear it on the outside, like the recipe suggests.
Suzanne says
I'm not the most experienced baker, so pardon what might seem like a stupid question. Did you just use ONE 9x13 pan and cut it into 3 layers? Or 3 9x13 pans? That cake looks awesome, I can't wait to try it. We're looking for a really moist vanilla cake for my daughter's upcoming wedding, this might be the one!!
Natalie says
No, don't be afraid to ask! I used one 9x13 pan and cut it into 3 layers. The cake is kind of dense, but it definitely helped to refrigerate the cake beforehand. This would be an amazing wedding cake!!
Susan Nickels says
Here is my trick... I used a 1/4 cup extra of strawberry jam that I sprinkled unflavored gelatin over. After letting set for 5 minutes I put the jam and gelatin mixture in the microwave for 15 second to melt the gelatin. Stir the warm mixture and let it come to room temperature. When making the frosting add this mixture to it. You will have the best frosting ever!
Chris says
Has anyone made it and froze it to serve at a later time?
Natalie says
I've never done it, but I'm sure the cake would freeze just fine. I don't know about the frosting, though. I'd just make the frosting right before assembly.
Cords says
you guys, I pinned this to pinterest and it has well over 6000 views! I hope you are getting some of that traffic! People love your cake! <3
Natalie says
I was watching it all day yesterday! I had more hits yesterday than I ever have in a single day. Incredible. It seems to be still going this morning. I wonder if that pin was Stumbled. Anyhow, thanks a million for the pin! :)
Ianna says
You did a terrific job. Looks so yummy.
I made something very similar after tasting such a cake filled with a variety of summer berries. The only difference is that I used whipping cream mixed in with melted semi-sweet white chocolate, a hint of vanilla. Because the chocolate was sweet, I didn't need to add more sugar. I also used jam to moisten the cake before adding the layer of berries & frosting, thinning out the jam first by boiling it with a little water.
Natalie says
Thanks! I love the idea of adding white chocolate. (Anything is better with some chocolate...brown or otherwise :))
rebecca says
The frosting ingredients and directions....heavy whipped cream? Is this the cool whip that is folded in or is it heavy cream in the milk section? The directions say to add the cream and then to fold in the whipped cream? I think I'm missing something.
rebecca says
ps. I too found this on pinterest and want to make it for MY birthday. :)
Natalie says
Hi Rebecca -- Sorry for the confusion! This is the liquid heavy whipping cream, not cool whip. The directions say this: "Beat cream in a separate, chilled, bowl until peaks form. Fold whipped cream into frosting." As in... beat the heavy whipping cream, and then fold THAT cream into the frosting. It's the same cream.
rebecca says
thank you. :)
Anjilee says
I just made this, and it was AMAZING! I loved the frosting and the taste of the cake itself. It was moist and yummy. I used 9 inch cake pans and I had a hell of a time assembling it. I finished the frosting, admired for a second, and then yelped as it all started melting apart! None the less, it was delicious! I will def make this again in a 9 X13 pan.
Natalie says
Oh no!! That seems to be the consensus... 9-inch rounds are a doozy to assemble. At least it tastes great, right!?
Graziela says
I've made this cake 3 times and use two 9" round pans. What I do though is I cut each cake in half vertically, making it a thin 4 layer cake. I made this cake for a church fundraising auction and it went for $140, it's a great recipe, and a favorite of mine, I look for any excuse to make it.
Natalie Perry says
WOW! I'm so glad it worked well for you! I wondered when you said vertically... LOL. The mental picture I was getting confused me. :)
Graziela says
OOPS!!! HORIZONTALLY!!!!! And I don't swirl jam on the icing either.
Kayla says
Have you ever made these into cupcakes or mini-cupcakes? Loved the recipe and looking to make it for an event but cupcakes would fit our crowd much better for simplicity. Just wondering if it would be too dry or if you had recommendations on bake time.
Natalie Perry says
Hi Kayla,
I assume it would work alright, but I've never tried it, so I can't give any accurate recommendations.
Kayla says
Sorry that was meant to be it's own comment, not a reply on yours!
Melissa says
1 lbs of butter. wow. this looks too good not to make.
Jessica says
Found it on Pintrest and it looks sooooo good. I'm planning on making it for my daughters 2nd Birthday party later this month!
Carrie says
I also saw this on Pinterest! I plan to make it for an upcoming company bake-off! It looks absolutely delicious!
Wendy says
Found this on Pinterest! I am definitely making this for Easter :)
Frankie says
Ok, just made this... Waiting for it to cool so I can use the amazing frosting, can't wait to try it..... Thanks for all the helpful comments..
AngieG says
I plan on trying this cake in the very near future. When I make boston cream pies, I cut my layers for my cake w/ sewing thread. Done while cake is still very warm. The thread glides right through the cake just have to keep it even.
Natalie says
What a great idea! Thanks for that awesome tip.
JenniferM says
My mom taught me that trick when i was little..im 41yrs young now. I used to think it was sooo neat. It glides right thru the cake...she used to do it to thake the hump off the top of round cakes so after its frosted the second cake would sit flat on top of the other cake.
Heather Ocallaghan says
Not sure what I did wrong but after 2 days in the fridge the icinf still did not get spreadable, only pourable. It was like pudding.I even added an extra 4 cups of powder sugar to it hoping that would thicken it up but it didn't. The taste was good, just couldn't put it on the cake. Had to put a spoonful on the plate next to the cake slice and dip the cake into it.
Rhonda says
I can't wait to try making this cake. My family is incharge of Easter dessert and am sure this will be a hit! Thank You! Loved reading all the tips and tricks in the comments.
Rhonda says
P.S. found it on Pinterest
Marty says
I found this cake on Pintrest. I've never made a cake from scratch before but here goes . . .cake is out of the oven and just flipped out of the pans for cooling. They don't look too white, more of a yellow cake look to them. I'm going to hold off on frosting them until tomorrow before company comes. I know, why would I try all this for the first time and expect to serve it for Easter . . . it looked sooooo good on Pintrest I just couldn't resist. I hope I don't have the same frosting issues that some of you have had. I did use the 2 9 inch pan method. I'll post how it turns out later.
Brenda says
I just made this cake for Easter dinner tomorrow. I baked a 12" and tiered it with a 9" cake. The frosting started to melt in the middle of the assembly and it slippery. The declaring looks a little "messy", but the taste is amazing. My husband even loved the left over frosting over the left over strawberries as a dessert! Happy Easter!
stephanie says
OMG!!!! I just made this for Easter (tomorrow) SO SO SO GOOD!! I had to try some...... YUUMMMMYYYY!!!!
stephanie says
WILL MAKE THIS AGAIN AND AGAIN!!!!!
Sarah Hammer says
I just made this for Easter tomorrow. I used two 9 inch pans and I also used the sewing thread to cut the cake in half when it was warm. Worked like a charm. I made sure the frosting was cold. I didn't put the cake in the fridge because my wire rack was too deep to fit. So I waited until the cake was room temp before assembly. It went together really well, I didn't have any major issues. I did notice by the time I got the 4 layers put together and it was time to frost around the outside of the cake, the frosting was not very cold and slid off the cake more. I had to work REALLY fast and get it in the fridge. So I would recommend maybe putting the frosting back in the fridge for about 15 minutes or so and then frosting the outside of the cake. I also left jam off the top layer because I saw a comment above about it being too sweet that way. Tomorrow I will shave some dark chocolate on top and decorate with strawberries. This was pretty easy, and not many steps, but be prepared to spend some time on it! Thanks for the recipe! I can't wait to show it off tomorrow (and then eat it, of course!).
Marty says
Just finished frosting the cake. Thanks to my dear husband - he's the artsy one in the family. Got the frosting on and put it back in the fridge till after Easter dinner. It looks a little messy, started to slide around a bit but that's the beauty of it I guess. It certainly looks homemade ;) I can't wait to taste it now. I dipped a few of the strawberries in the left over frosting and it tasted devine. Thank you so much for sharing this with us. Happy Easter to everyone.
Cristi Cook says
wow-what a great idea if you don't have time to make butterflies-just dip the berries and put on top-yummy!!
Alyssa says
Made this for Easter and now my husband wants this for his birthday! Best cake! Huge compliment that he is requesting this over his all-time favorite...red velvet!
Sharyna says
I made this cake last night at a customer's request and it is fabulous!!! I followed the recipe exactly this first time, but can see many variations of it working!!! I made it as a 1/4 sheet and only cut it into 2 layers, but can see how beautiful it would be as a round or square cake with several layers of the jam, frosting and fresh strawberries!!! What a wonderful spring/summer cake!!! Thanks!
Natalie says
You're welcome! Yes... you can do a lot of things with this! My 4yo wants this cake again except with blueberries. I'm excited to see how it turns out :) Glad you enjoyed it!
Brandi says
Oh my! I pinned this one a while back and just finished it for my daughter's 5th birthday party tomorrow. I baked the cake last night and put it in the fridge until tonight. I had the frosting in the fridge for about three hours before frosting the cake and didn't have any issues with it sliding. It turned out great and we enjoyed eating the "cake scraps" with a dab of the frosting. My husband says this is now my "go to" yellow cake. It has the best combination of moistness and density and the flavor is outstanding. The whipped cream in the cream cheese frosting is the best! We went to put the cake in the fridge and it is SO heavy! I piped melted chocolate flowers on the sides and wrote on the top and it looks darling. I can't wait for e eryone to enjoy it tomorrow! Thanks for such a great recipe!!!
Natalie says
So glad it worked well! I was getting nervous with all of the comments about the frosting being too runny. *Phew* Enjoy tomorrow!
Melody D. says
I've heard so many good things about this cake! I teach and make cheese so I have a big batch of freshly made cream cheese to use for this recipe. My son's 3rd birthday is on the 5th of May so I think he'll love it.
Meg says
OMG, this cake looks heavenly! And those butterflies, so beautiful, so lovely. I love strawberries and I've just bought some, so I was looking for some cake recipe. Last year in the strawberry season I've made a fantastic cake with white chocolate, but now I wanted to try something new. I found this recipe at Pinterest and cannot wait to make it, but probably I'll cut the ingredients by half. Thanks
Ellie says
I made this cake for a birthday party yesterday, and it was A) so easy, and B) INSANELY DELICIOUS! Thank you! I will definitely be making it again!
Desiree says
I'm totally drooling right now... One of my girls has a birthday coming up next week and despite her lack of love for the color pink, I think I'm just going to go ahead and make this cake! lol
Elizabeth says
I made this cake this morning, with a few variations.
1) Instead of 2 tsp vanilla extract, I used 1 tsp vanilla extract and 1 tsp almond extract. 2) I made 3 layers and didn't cut them in half. 3) I used raspberry preserves (strained, so seedless) and frozen raspberries, instead of strawberry preserves and strawberries.
The cake came out moist and is one of the most delicious white cakes I've ever made (and I've made a lot!)
Cristi Cook says
I LOVE your butterflies-definitely want to try those with my granddaughters who love to help me in the kitchen-especially something this beautiful. I just picked fresh strawberries, so hopefully will get a chance to at least make the cake-can't wait!! PS-I've taken 5 cake class series-and your writing is great!! :)
Roberta keene says
Has anyone tried to just leave it as a single layer in the 9x13 pan?
Jessica says
This looks heavenly!! There can never ever be enough desserts with strawberries. Yum!
Teryn says
i am so excited to try and make this cake my daughter loves butterflies so she will love this for her fourth birthday in september but i am gona practice making it for the fourth of july
Kristin says
I am making this cake right now, and it smells HEAVENLY! I can't wait to put it together for my mom's birthday party later! I haven't decided what to do about decorations...probably something simple. I have a feeling that I have an awesome new GO TO vanilla cake! Thank you!!!
Rehab says
Thanks Alot. Can I use buttermilk or yougert instead of sour cream?
Thanks agian :)
Natalie says
I'd use Greek yogurt if you're going to substitute. Buttermilk doesn't have the same texture as sour cream. Good luck!
Pat says
Looks yummy and can't wait to try. To cut the layers, I use dental floss...much sturdier and works well.
Maria says
Hey! I made this cake today for my daughters birthday, and it is amazing. I did a 3 layer round cake, and had to keep refrigerating the frosting and cake, because the frosting is runny, and the cake was melting. But the frosting is so good! I only used one container of strawberries, because my daughters ran off with the other container and ate every last one! But it worked out. :) Thanks for the recipe!
Ginger says
This cake was very good and rich. I did the four layers with the round cake pans. Before cutting the two round cakes in half I did put them in the fridge and it helped. I did make the frosting ahead of time and no matter how long I left it in the fridge it never became any thicker.
It was still yummy just not picture perfect and I had quite a bit of icing left over so I just froze it.
Mandy says
I "pinned" this recipe months ago with my daughter's 8th birthday in mind-- she LOVES strawberries! We had her party yesterday and it was a huge hit!!! Delicious and beautiful!! The icing is heavenly!! It was a show stopper!
Bobbie says
Made this last week and OMG. Everytime my boyfriend eats a piece of it he says this is the BEST cake I have ever made. Thank You.
Shelby says
I was just wondering, I want to make a round cake instead of a square one. I know that it won't be as big, so how much less should I use? I'm sure I will have a lot left over if I use the whole 7 eggs and what not. Help please!
Natalie Perry says
Hi Shelby! Just use three of those standard, round cake pans. That's what the original called for anyway. Best of luck!
Shelby says
Another question, do you have to use a beater or electric mixer? Or can you just hand mix it?
Natalie Perry says
Sorry for the late reply! You could mix it by hand, but I would highly recommend a mixer (or a hand-held mixer) so the ingredients can be incorporated fully.
Carrie says
This cake was absolutely awesome! I made this for my mother in law's birthday yesterday. I did it as a 9 inch round stacked cake. I didn't have a big problem with the icing sliding around, I did however, stick the cake in the freezer after I had iced it to let it harden just a bit. Probably 25 mins. Then I took it out and put it in the fridge until time to celebrate. I will make this cake again. It was incredibly delicious. Loved it! Probably one of the best-tasting cakes I've ever made!
Cynthia says
Hello!! Your cake looks delicious!! I am actually doing a chocolate ganache frosting, but am very excited to use your recipe as my cake!! Quick question, can I use Fage Greek yogurt in place of sour cream?
Natalie Perry says
Yes! I think that would work just fine as long as the yogurt is full-fat.
Fatima says
Hello! I'm wondering if the ingredients' measurements listed are for 12 people or for the size of the cake you made for your daughter. I will be making the cake right now. Thank you!
Natalie Perry says
Both. The 12 servings are pretty generous and stretched out to about 20 smaller servings. I guess it depends on how hungry your guests are. :)
Shannon says
Just put my cake together and can't wait to dive in tonight. Followed your recipe exactly and had no problem assembling the cake, although I used less frosting, strawberries and jam than you suggested in between the layers (just enough to make sure you knew it was there). With 2 - 9" round pans I ended up with a 3 layer cake. Refrigerated the cake and frosting overnight and the next day slapped it together on a 10" cake caddy. Thank you for the recipe! I've shared it with everyone I know :)
Shannon says
I suppose I should also mention that I live on the prairies and its the middle this time of year!
kim says
Does it make a difference if I use splenda instead of sugar? I made it with splenda and it didn't rise at all. That's the only thing I changed in the recipe.. I guess its a good thing I tried it before Easter dinner.
Natalie Perry says
Hi Kim. I'm sorry it didn't work! I do not buy Splenda so I'm not familiar with its effects in baked goods.
rebecca says
your cake looks soo good!! I'm making it right now but unfortunately I do not have all the ingredients for the frosting :(...so I'm going to try it with store bought frosting...
rebecca says
oh, also I didn't have any unsalted butter on hand because I usually use salted butter, I hope it doesn't make too much of a difference..
blt2boo says
I made this and took it to work. It was a huge hit!
I put jam in the icing but made a strawberry purée, ran it through cheesecloth and added grand marnier & sugar (to taste) for the genoise. I had no problem with assembly by keeping everything chilled prior to and during putting it all together. This method works if you do not want to add gelatin to the frosting as mentioned earlier. Putting it in the freezer for 20-30 minutes afterwards, then storing in the refrigerator until time to cut helped keep it all together.
I also made a second cake and exchanged half of the regular sugar with light brown sugar, as well as adding 1 Tbsp of vanilla bean paste to the vanilla already called for in the recipe. This gave the cake a lovely richness to the taste. As a previous comment said, there are all kinds if possibilities with this cake. However, the adapted recipe is a real keeper just as it is.
I highly recommend adding this to your favorites!
Jess says
Hi, I'm wondering if this cake could be made with raspberries instead of strawberries?
Natalie Perry says
Sure!
Shae says
I want to make mini cakes out of your recipe for a baby shower I am catering and would like to know if you recommend freezing to keep frosting together or just adding the packet of unflavored gelatin to the frosting
Natalie Perry says
I didn't have problems with the frosting, but many people did. If it worries you and you're comfortable adapting the recipe, then go for it!
Megan says
I made this cake yesterday for my daughter's 8th birthday, complete with the chocolate butterflies. It turned out really cute and the butterflies were not nearly as difficult to make as I feared. I do think the recipe needs a little tweaking, though. First of all, I used two 9-in rounds as the recipe stated and they were so full, by the time the middle was set, the outside was much darker than I would have preferred, resulting in a somewhat dry cake and portions that had to be shaved off. Second, the frosting. I have made cream cheese frosting numerous times for different cupcake and cake recipes and not a single one called for whipping cream. The cream cheese already makes the frosting so soft and unstable, I just can't see how it would even be possible to work with it with the addition of cream, even if it was thoroughly whipped. So I left out the cream, making a standard CC frosting. Also, the best tip I've come across with regard to CC frosting is to make sure the cheese is VERY cold when mixing up the frosting. The butter can be at room temp, but the cheese needs to come straight from the fridge. Even with my adjustments, I still had to keep it refrigerated before, during, and after the cake was assembled, which I feel affected the overall taste since the cake was served cold instead of room temp. My daughter was happy with it, and while I will definitely make the butterflies and maybe the overall style of cake again, I think there are other recipes that are a little easier to work with and just as good.
Stephanie Masanz says
Yummy! I had to try this cake as soon as I saw the picture. It was so incredibly good! The butterflies you made are amazing! Definitely going to make this again. It was a huge hit with the whole family.
relly says
Hi natalie, tried to see whether you had a moment to post the tutorial on making butterflies. Is it there? Cldnt find it. Also did you use chocolate frosting to do the writing and borders? Thks
Natalie Perry says
Hi Relly! The tutorial is here: https://www.perrysplate.com/2009/05/chocolate-monarch-butterflies.html
And yes, I used chocolate frosting for the writing.
April says
Hi there! I was wondering if you think this recipe would be suitable as cupcakes. Thanks!
Natalie Perry says
Sure! Go for it!
Christine says
Love this cake and made it last year for Mother's Day. I just made it again, and darn it, thought it said 2 eggs. I was looking it over again after I put it in the oven, and saw it needs 7! Do I start over??
kimberly says
I made this cake and it was like eating a Little Debbie's Jelly roll. I will not make it again. Sorry
Jill says
I made this cake and it was a huge hit! My husband said best cake ever!! Going to try making cupcakes with same recipe to take to a picnic. Thanks.
Kendr says
How did cupcakes go?
Lydia says
I've made this several time and love it! Question: If I wanted to use almond extract would I use it an addition to some vanilla or instead of? And would the conversion be the same, 2 T? Thanks!
Natalie Perry says
Good to hear! You could replace all of the vanilla extract with almond if you like or do half and half. I don't use almond extract so I'm not sure if it has the same potency. I'd go half and half to be safe. :)
krchadwell says
Note to self. Used cream cheese straight from fridge. Used almond instead of vanilla. Used 2 - 10 inch pans. Used cold water soaked, bake-even strips on cake pans. Baked 50 minute. Sliced strawberries with egg slicer, single layer on paper towel to dry. Also, pat dry top side with paper towel. Could use 3/4 of icing recipe, makes a lot of icing - or could just use more icing between layers. Also, put some icing on plate before adding the first slice of cake.
Jill says
Best cake ever....
Mara says
Is the cake flour non-self rising cake flour?? I'd like to make this for Easter :)
Mara says
The flour used is it non-self rising cake flour?? I'd like to make this for Easter :)
Lisa Wallace says
I have made this cake for several events since you posted it! It is my very favorite cake!!
Thanks for sharing the recipe!
resep puding dan cara membuat agar-agar busa says
hmmm, look delicious cake
Courtney says
Great cake! Did someone mention on here that the cake possibly sinks in the middle, otherwise it was very good. I thought I read it somewhere, but can't seem to find it. Maybe it was another recipe.
Beth B. says
Strawberry season is upon us once again and I prepare to make this fantastic cake for the third year in a row. I look for any excuse to bring cake do events during the spring. There's usually a good bit of frosting left over. It's delicious on crackers (think sweet/salty), on fresh baked bread or plain. The butterflies also look so elegant and leave me marveling at the delectable and beautiful cake.
Note- raspberry preserves/fresh raspberries can be subbed for strawberries. I'd recommend decreasing the sugar in the frosting though because raspberry preserves seem to be a good bit sweeter than strawberry.
Natalie Perry says
So glad you enjoy it so much! Thanks for the tips. xoxo
Moriah says
WARNING This might be blasphemous for some of you.
So if you want to do this recipe but are a little lazy (like me) and not a regular baker (like me) and don't want to do everything COMPLETELY from scratch, do as I did this past weekend:
For a one layer 9X13 pan, I halved the entire Frosting recipe (I still had some frosting leftover). Then I bought a box of Duncan Hines Vanilla cake batter, made as directed on the box and just added the jam and the berries as indicated in the recipe above.
Still takes some time but I think significantly less. It was so moist and delicious and is my husband's new favorite. I think this would be great with fresh strawberry slices sprinkled on top as well.
One day, when I'm feeling particularly adventurous, I will try to do the whole recipe from scratch.
Matthew Moore says
I made this recipe a few years ago, then lost the recipe and I found it again! I'm so glad to have found it, because I want to make it again for my daughter's birthday!
Brooke says
I’m going to try this for my little girls first birthday and the LOVEs strawberries. Do you think I can puree or dice strawberries and put it into the actual cake ...or is that a step too far?
AnnMarie Cardin says
This came looks so delicious. I don’t often make cakes but I would love to start. I have one question. When you slice the cakes in half (I’ve heard plain, unwaxed, unflavored dental floss is a good tool), and you say “place cake side down”, what does that mean? It’s all cake. Did you mean cut side down? Or the opposite?
Thanks for your time! Can’t wait to try this recipe!
XO AnnMarie
Natalie Perry says
Ack, yes. CUT side down. Thanks for catching that!
Latifat says
Hi! Can I substitute the strawberries with mangoes ?
Natalie Perry says
I've never made it like that, so I can't say whether it will work well or not. Mangoes have a higher moisture content, so I'd keep that in mind for sure if you try it out.
Carina says
hello, so I have made this multiple times but never printed the recipe. Well since the update there doesn't seem to be an ingredient list. So, now I am really bummed since I love your recipe, but can't find it.
Kat says
I’m nervous to make this! I’ve always used oil in my cakes and I’m worrier using butter will lead to a dry cake!
Elena Bjostad says
This looks amazing! I do not care for cream cheese though. Can the frosting be made using some other ingredients? thanks!
Natalie Perry says
Hi Elena! You can just make regular buttercream frosting if you don't want to use cream cheese.
Kendra Reynolds says
I swear this recipe used to call for cake flour. Did you change it? Does it make a difference?
Natalie Perry says
It did and yes, I changed it. I've made it over and over with regular all-purpose flour and it didn't make that big of a difference. It was maybe a smidgen more dense, but you can definitely use cake flour if you prefer.
Tiffany says
Can this recipe be done in a 9 inch dome cake pan?
Wayne Berry says
The cake turned out great. I let the frosting chill in the fridge for a few hours before I could get it cooperate. I think next time I'll add gelatin as I've read in the comments.